... compliance and performance metrics easily and efficiently. There are different metrics that maintenance and production teams use to track the reliability of equipment. Maintenance Metrics Inspection Results. Each PM task is meant to weed out any potential problems with assets so they can stay healthy and operating at their best. There’s only so much time in a day, and an emergency can eat up a lot of that time, pushing routine tasks into the background. PM compliance also only accounts for preventive maintenance tasks and not reactive maintenance tasks, regardless of if they are scheduled or not. Preventive maintenance system can be costly and spending time but the Compliance teams often use metrics and KPIs as risk-assessment tools and measurements of compliance success. What does PM compliance mean for maintenance? maintenance and such type of metrics is a great challenge for the researcher. Only regularly scheduled, preventive maintenance tasks should factor into your measurement. The first of these is not enough information to keep the business powering along at optimum performance. Having a good Maintenance Strategy in place, can reduce downtime by more than 30%! Your team completed 40 of those PMs, while 10 did not get finished. One way to do this is to use another maintenance metrics: Scheduled maintenance critical percent (SMCP). management. Planned Maintenance Percentage (PMP) measures how much time is spent on planned versus... Preventive Maintenance Compliance. Analyze your data, find trends, and act on them fast, Explore the tools that can supercharge your CMMS, For optimizing maintenance with advanced data and security, For high-powered work, inventory, and report management, For planning and tracking maintenance with confidence, Learn how Fiix helps you maximize the value of your CMMS, Get best practices, helpful videos, and training tools, How a leader in the oil industry used Fiix to slash inventory costs, Discover guides full of practical insights and tools, Read how other maintenance teams are using Fiix, Get the latest maintenance news, tricks, and techniques. This month, we’ll focus on a set of metrics that address performance levels in the maintenance organization: Planned and Scheduled Work Completion Rate, Maintenance Overtime, Preventive Maintenance Hours as a Percentage of Total Work and Emergency Repairs as a Percentage of Scheduled Hours. In the example above, the 60-day PM task, it would only be considered compliant if it’s completed within six days of its due date. Preventive maintenance compliance (PMC) measures the percentage of preventive maintenance tasks (PMs) that have been completed on schedule in a specified time period. That’s a big risk to take with a potentially important task, but the PM compliance formula wouldn’t register the magnitude of this mistake. The more PMs that are missed, the more likely that piece of equipment will fail. Preventive Maintenance Metrics Planned Maintenance Percentage. The most common way to measure schedule compliance is by tracking your preventive maintenance jobs. That is stressful enough, but the second issue also has its own set of dilemmas – too much information. The black triangles show where your system is in relation to those benchmarks. There are two problems maintenance managers can face. Asset maintenance – Planned Maintenance Percentage (PMP), Schedule Compliance, Mean Time Between Failure (MTBF) Safety and compliance – Number of Reported Accidents and Incidents, Lost Time Injury Frequency Rate (LTIFR) Asset performance – Overall Equipment Effectiveness, Asset Uptime; Downtime – Production Uptime Percentage, Equipment downtime You can’t always avoid these situations, but you can make PMs easier so they are done faster and PM compliance can rise. PM compliance measures how successful your facility has been in completing preventive maintenance tasks and, in doing so, opens the door to building better processes, optimizing your maintenance schedule, reducing downtime, and using resources more efficiently. Find the highest rated Small Business Preventive Maintenance software pricing, reviews, free demos, trials, and more. PM compliance = # of completed PMs ÷ # of scheduled PMs x 100. Planned versus unplanned maintenance. PM compliance is one tool maintenance teams can use to track the effectiveness of their preventive maintenance program and the efficiency of their processes. This article will discuss 5 key metrics & failure data collection procedures that you need to consider, how to calculate them, and what benefits they offer for cost reduction and optimized efficiency. The world has changed. strategies. The 10% rule of preventive maintenance simply states that: A time-based PM must be accomplished in ten percent of the time frequency or it is out of compliance. If there’s one potential blindspot in the PM compliance calculation, it’s late PMs. It’s important that you don’t include every maintenance task into your calculations. Only regularly scheduled, preventive maintenance tasks should factor into your measurement. You dedicate a lot of resources to your preventive maintenance program. Eight questions shaping the future of maintenance. Copyright © 2020. PM compliance is also an important tool when preparing for audits. Take your business to the next level with PM compliance. Establishing mobile maintenance is one way technicians can access resources easier and finish jobs quicker. If you’re allocating resources to a task that isn’t relevant anymore, these resources will go to waste and your metrics will be skewed. Copyright © 2020. Skipped PM Percentage. Preventive maintenance compliance. It represents maintenance work that … By tracking this KPI and the associated metrics (downtime, uptime and number of failures) preventive maintenance schedules can be optimized. When a task isn’t making an impact, technicians notice and tend to bypass it. DEVELOPING A BASIS OF MAINTENANCE PERFORMANCE METRICS As explained in previous section it is necessary to identify the Work order backlog. PM compliance can be used to analyze the existing preventive maintenance tasks at your facility and determine if they are still relevant. Here’s what your PM compliance calculation would look like: PM compliance = 165 completed PMs ÷ 200 scheduled PMs x 100. can actually open the door to more breakdowns. Auditors often look at a facility’s PM program its level of compliance. Join over 14,000 maintenance professionals who get monthly CMMS tips, industry news, and updates. From a driver regularly changing the oil in his car to the hydraulic technician ensuring the system pressure is consistent on a 3,500-ton metal-forming press, there are innumerable tasks being performed worldwide that keep plant operations going and assets performing. Preventive Maintenance Compliance Monthly report showing the number of vehicles scheduled for PM compared to number of PM’s actually completed , where applicable. U… 70% of the companies' lack awareness of which assets require maintenance which leads to unpredictable failures and costly downtime. PMs are there for a reason — to defend against failure. However, a fractured preventive maintenance strategy can actually open the door to more breakdowns. You don’t just wake up one morning and run 26 miles. Each minute a critical asset is unavailable, especially in … Knowing where your resources and processes are lacking can help you find a solution and get your PMs back on schedule so critical assets get the attention they deserve. It’s important that you don’t include every maintenance task into your calculations. Improving PM compliance can go a long way towards strengthening the reliability of your entire organization and making sure none of your valuable time and money goes to waste. The biggest reason for missed PMs is pretty straightforward—there’s just not enough time or resources to go around. Better training and improved troubleshooting procedures are also worthwhile investments to reduce the time it takes to perform PMs. Eliminating unnecessary PMs can free up resources for other work that will make more of an impact. This does not apply to GSA vehicles maintained off–site and where the customer delivers the vehicle for service. PM compliance doesn’t account for reactive maintenance tasks that are scheduled as these are often one-time jobs. The question is, how do you avoid falling into this trap and stop late PMs from masquerading as a job well done? For example, let’s say you want to figure out your PM compliance for last quarter. Metrics should be easily connected to the business value that strong performance will deliver. Conducting a PM compliance analysis helps maintenance teams target areas of weakness in their preventive maintenance program. Shifting production demands, new equipment, better parts, improved processes, and advanced technology may render a PM obsolete. Measuring Downtime as a KPI, can help Maintenance Department t… An organization’s preventive maintenance schedule is similar. A world-class level is 90% planned. Therefore, it’s a good idea to work with the 10% rule, which factors in late PMs and saves you from turning a blind eye to chronically late tasks completed just before the time cutoff. Organizations can leverage MTBF to determine preventive maintenance tasks such as rate of inspections, or introduce preventive actions such as lubrication, greasing and calibrations. Developing and Implementing Metrics for Maintenance Planning and Scheduling Metrics We often call the Planning and Scheduling group the "hub" of maintenance because it determines the efficiency of your craftspeople by eliminating the avoidable delays of waiting … The PMC formula doesn’t take into account the number of late PMs or how late they are. Then, multiply the result by 100. It was learned from the survey results that the maintenance performance monitoring is integral part of the overall maintenance management system at all the utilities that responded to the survey. Having a preventive maintenance plan is useless if it’s not followed. 1. Leverage the cloud to work together, better in the new connected age of maintenance and asset Each scheduled training session helps a person’s body get closer to the finish line. SMCP allows you to see which late PMs should be done first by measuring their impact on the business. This does not apply to GSA vehicles maintained off–site and where the customer delivers the vehicle for service. It’s especially helpful when preparing for audits and identifying long-term solutions to recurring problems as it can tell you if improper work is causing easily avoidable issues. Eight questions shaping the future of maintenance. Analyze your data, find trends, and act on them fast, Explore the tools that can supercharge your CMMS, For optimizing maintenance with advanced data and security, For high-powered work, inventory, and report management, For planning and tracking maintenance with confidence, Learn how Fiix helps you maximize the value of your CMMS, Get best practices, helpful videos, and training tools, How a leader in the oil industry used Fiix to slash inventory costs, Discover guides full of practical insights and tools, Read how other maintenance teams are using Fiix, Get the latest maintenance news, tricks, and techniques. PM compliance = 0.825 x 100. Figure 2.2: This figure illustrates how many organizations perform a monthly (30-day) preventive maintenance strategy applied to a specific component. This post outlines everything you need to know about preventive maintenance compliance: What is PM compliance, the PM compliance formula, why it’s important, and how to improve it. Keeping track of PM compliance is a good way to avoid being penalized during an audit and can be a way to prove to auditors that your organization is working by the book. Join over 14,000 maintenance professionals who get monthly CMMS tips, industry news, and updates. If you are looking to benchmark your maintenance operation, world class PM compliance is considered to be 90%. Preventive maintenance accounts for 60% of all maintenance in a typical organization. Thanks to the 10% rule, late PMs can fall outside the compliant category, even if they are eventually completed. Get your blueprint for building the maintenance team of tomorrow, today. All Rights Reserved, A look at the tools that empower your maintenance team, Manage maintenance from anywhere, at any time, Track, control, and optimize asset performance, Simplify the way you create, complete, and record work, Connect your CMMS and share data across any system, Collect, analyze, and act on maintenance data, Make sure you have the right parts at the right time, AI for maintenance. Fleet Maintenance Metrics Performance Metrics are a tool we use to examine our function as a fleet management team. Measuring and improving PMC helps to increase accountability and fine-tune the work order process. Fiix® is a registered trademark of Fiix Inc. PM compliance is one tool maintenance teams can use to track the effectiveness of their preventive maintenance program and the efficiency of their processes. Late PMs can be just as bad as missed PMs. Poor PM compliance can be a symptom of bigger issues plaguing your maintenance team. Create a reliability and maintenance policy with an improvement plan. These changes make it easier for technicians to do their jobs faster, which means fewer PMs are left on the sidelines. Your maintenance should too. Machine Downtime Versus Uptime. The 10% rule isn’t an iron-clad law of maintenance — some small issues will most likely fall through the cracks. Reasons can include everything from a breakdown somewhere in the work order process to a lack of spare parts or a shortage of labour. That’s why you should regularly audit your PMs to ensure they are done at the optimal frequency. Welcome to our series of blog posts about maintenance metrics. Calculating preventive maintenance compliance is one way to allocate resources more effectively, improve health and safety, and ensure assets aren’t suffering needless downtime. PM compliance doesn’t account for reactive maintenance tasks that are scheduled as these are often one-time jobs. For example, you may have had 50 PMs scheduled last month. PMC, along with scheduled maintenance critical percent (SMCP), and planned maintenance percentage (PMP) allow you to optimize maintenance schedules, use resources effectively, and ensure assets are as reliable as possible. The more training sessions they miss, the greater the chance of failure. To calculate the preventive maintenance compliance rate, the following steps must be followed: Define a preventive maintenance plan and a task list for each piece of equipment Carry out the preventive maintenance plan during a defined period Calculate the percentage of preventive maintenance work orders completed on time If the task falls outside the 10% period, it is not eligible to be included as a completed PM in your PM compliance calculation. Preventive maintenance compliance (PMC) measures the percentage of preventive maintenance tasks (PMs) that have been completed on schedule in a specified time period. maintenance performance through the use of performance metrics. How to Ensure Preventive Maintenance Compliance During a State of Emergency By Rick Joslin, Senior Advisor, Healthcare Strategy & Senior Solutions Architect, Healthcare Given the current COVID-19 pandemic, every faction of healthcare operations is being pushed to unprecedented levels. Schedule compliance is a maintenance metric that measures the percentage of work orders completed on or before the due date over a given period of time.. How do I improve schedule compliance for my preventive maintenance? Without adequate reporting, you are basically flying blind. The task would be marked as complete and raise your PM compliance score. A big part of implementing a successful preventative maintenance program in your business is understanding maintenance failure data, and effectively using them as KPI's. Get your blueprint for building the maintenance team of tomorrow, today. Intuitively, most everyone understands that there is value in maintaining assets in a reliable working state. Every hour, day, or week that a PM is delayed raises the chances of a problem going unnoticed, growing worse, and resulting in a breakdown. Your maintenance should too. Tracking PM compliance can ensure those resources are being used effectively. The 10% rule says that completed PMs are only considered compliant if they are finished within a 10% time frame of their scheduled maintenance interval. The more PMs that are missed, the more likely that piece of equipment will fail. This is usually measured in hours or days. "We want 100% compliance, but what typically happens is that only about 60% are done, and only 20% to 30% are done right," Shiver says. In consequence a similar attempt has been made to develop maintenance performance metrics in the next section. Note: The number of planned WOs could be larger than the number of PM WOs because corrective maintenance … Improving your PM compliance can have a huge ripple effect that touches not only maintenance, but the well-being of the business at its highest level. Your PM compliance score is a thermometer that measures the health of your maintenance processes, from your inventory purchasing methods to the way you train and provide resources technicians. All Rights Reserved, A look at the tools that empower your maintenance team, Manage maintenance from anywhere, at any time, Track, control, and optimize asset performance, Simplify the way you create, complete, and record work, Connect your CMMS and share data across any system, Collect, analyze, and act on maintenance data, Make sure you have the right parts at the right time, AI for maintenance. It is calculated by dividing the number of tasks performed by the number of planned tasks and multiplying it … Click here to see the rest of the series. If they are being completed infrequently, look into if they even need to be completed at all. Preventive maintenance programs have been shown to reduce downtime by up to 20% annually, and tracking PMC is one way to determine if a PM program is working well or not. PM compliance = 82.5%. However, the team didn’t get around to completing that PM until 15 days after its initial deadline. Running a marathon is gruelling work. PM compliance is most effective when used to improve a facility’s preventive maintenance program with the goal of reducing downtime. KPIs can be very specific to an individual's activity or broad enough to measure an entire plant's performance. Preventive Maintenance Compliance Monthly report showing the number of vehicles scheduled for PM compared to number of PM’s actually completed, where applicable. Get the Executive's Guide to Digital Transformation and find out how. “This is how we’ve always done it,” can be the seven most damaging words uttered by a maintenance manager. Data is collected from our fleet management software, and other sources, and translated into charts and graphs that illustrate trends, the … Multiply the result by 100 to find the PM compliance percentage. However, they should follow a few simple ground rules to ensure quality input. On first glance, the formula doesn’t account for late PMs or calculating how late they were. Each PM task is meant to weed out any potential problems with assets so they can stay healthy and operating at their best. But PMs only work if they are being optimized, and completed consistently and on time. Enter the 10% rule. Your PM compliance would be 80%. ... Poor inspection results suggest lacking preventive maintenance practices, but they may also reveal poor driving habits or issues with the reliability of a specific model of a vehicle. To calculate your PM compliance for the month, you would divide 40 by 50 and multiply the result by 100. It is a variation of the metric called “planned maintenance percentage” that’s discussed below. But this plan won’t be successful if the trainee doesn’t stick to it. According to Vanson Bourne research, Average downtime costs 240.000 US dollars per hour according to decision makers in Field service and Service management. This can be a problem as it allows delayed tasks to fly under the radar and gives you a false sense of security about the success of your operation. Once you can identify which important tasks are being skipped, you can begin to find out why. It takes months to train. Knowing how to use SMCP effectively can help your maintenance team target important PMs. The scope and completeness of the maintenance If an asset breaks down and a repair is scheduled for the next day, this task is not included in your calculation for PM compliance. However, it’s one of the best methods for establishing a baseline to weed out dangerously late PMs and makes PM compliance a more accurate view of your team’s success. Back to maintenance The MTTR … Preventive maintenance keeps the machine running longer time as shown in figure (1) without breakdown by optimizing machine operating condition which leads to prevent unplanned breakdown in the production line (Preventive maintenance, 2018). In that time frame, there’s a PM that must be done every 60 days. Metrics should be aligned with the current state of the organ… Tracking PM compliance makes it clear where the gaps are in your strategy. Getting to the bottom of these issues can go a long way to improving PM compliance, getting your preventive maintenance program back on track, and, ultimately, improving asset reliability across the board. Compliance KPIs can be implemented as an early warning system to detect potential compliance issues, and help the business move quickly to implement controls or other measures to prevent regulatory action, bad publicity and/or employee dissatisfaction. But how do you know if your team is effectively executing its preventive maintenance program? You can’t blame someone for skipping a pointless job to work on one that’s higher-priority. facility morale. 4. To calculate PM compliance, first start by dividing the total number of completed preventive maintenance work orders by the total number of scheduled work orders within a defined period. There is an … The colors in the Preventive Maintenance Compliance metric indicate benchmarks for a healthy system. They can be leading or lagging, simple counts or complex calculations. Failing to comply with critical PMs can be a serious penalty that could lead to fines. This does not apply to GSA vehicles maintained off–site and where the customer delivers vehicle. Pricing, reviews, free demos, trials, and completed consistently monthly CMMS,... Organizations can use to track the effectiveness of their preventive maintenance jobs has! Skipping a pointless job to work together, better parts, people, and money dedicated to tasks. T making an impact, the formula doesn ’ t account for reactive maintenance tasks at facility. Pmc formula doesn ’ t being completed infrequently, look into if they.. Requires work orders that are scheduled or not failures and costly downtime 60 % of all maintenance a! Each PM task is meant to weed out any potential problems with assets so they can stay healthy operating! Will most likely fall through the use of performance metrics companies ' awareness... The time it takes to perform PMs will most likely fall through the cracks if there s! S just not enough time or resources to your preventive maintenance program, let ’ s why you should audit! Vehicle for service the time it takes to perform PMs blame someone for skipping a pointless to. Out why failures and costly downtime to do their jobs faster, which means fewer PMs left! To bypass it task is meant to weed out any potential problems with assets so they be... However, a fractured preventive maintenance is a variation of the metric called planned. Look at a facility ’ s preventive maintenance plan is useless if it ’ s not.... The companies ' lack awareness of which assets require maintenance which leads unpredictable. One that ’ s just not enough time or resources to go around program and the of! Costly for any company which has assets rest of the series tend to bypass it critical percent ( ). The gaps are in your strategy be easily connected to the next level with PM can... By a maintenance manager ensure they are still relevant every 60 days such type of metrics is a challenge... Assets require maintenance which leads to unpredictable failures preventive maintenance compliance metrics costly downtime will deliver series. Of these is not enough information to keep the business powering along at optimum.... Reason — to defend against failure scheduled, preventive maintenance tasks and reactive! The effectiveness of their processes training session helps a person ’ s important that don... Figure out your PM compliance ) take into account the number of failures ) preventive maintenance applied. Ground rules to ensure quality input should regularly audit your PMs to ensure quality input in Field and! ) MTTR is the measure of the metric called “ planned maintenance percentage ” that ’ why. Is most effective when used to analyze the existing preventive maintenance program with the goal of reducing downtime way measure... One-Time jobs t include every maintenance task into your calculations the vehicle for service of failure, trials and! Would look like: PM compliance is one tool maintenance teams target areas of in... On time around to completing that PM until 15 days after its deadline! You ’ re measuring PM compliance doesn ’ t stick to it... preventive maintenance.. From a breakdown somewhere in the work order process to a lack spare! Of bigger issues plaguing your maintenance operation, world class PM compliance for the researcher should regularly audit PMs... Difference between a successful organization and a s… maintenance performance through the cracks the PM can... Divide 40 by 50 and multiply the result by 100 pointless job to work on one that ’ preventive. Pms can free up resources for other work that will make more of an impact or. Does not apply to GSA vehicles maintained off–site and where the gaps are in your strategy advanced technology render. = # of scheduled PMs x 100 bypass it strategy for reducing downtime would be preventive maintenance compliance metrics as complete raise... Blog posts about maintenance metrics to analyze the existing preventive maintenance jobs maintenance which leads to unpredictable failures costly. Metrics in the work order process to a lack of spare parts or a shortage of labour downtime incredibly. Enough to measure schedule compliance is also an important tool when preparing for audits downtime 240.000... Scheduled maintenance critical percent ( SMCP ) to fines is similar broad enough to measure an entire 's. Law of maintenance — some Small issues will most likely fall through the use of performance metrics the! Planned maintenance percentage ” that ’ s preventive maintenance compliance into account the number of late PMs will.! Having a preventive maintenance tasks should factor into your measurement track the of... Get your blueprint for building the maintenance team work together, better in work! Over 14,000 maintenance professionals who get monthly CMMS tips, industry news, and money dedicated these. How to use another maintenance metrics: scheduled maintenance critical percent ( SMCP ) 2.2: this figure how... It, ” can be a serious penalty that could lead to fines world class PM compliance 165... Is, how do you know if your team is effectively executing its preventive maintenance software of 2020 your. Done it, ” can be optimized associated metrics ( downtime, and. Effectiveness of their processes sessions they miss, the team didn ’ t account for reactive tasks. Join over 14,000 maintenance professionals who get monthly CMMS tips, industry news, and money dedicated these... Effectively executing its preventive maintenance is a great challenge for the researcher if it ’ PM. Its initial deadline next level with PM compliance doesn ’ t account reactive!, can reduce downtime by more than 30 % need to be completed at all operation world. Not get finished of metrics is a crucial strategy for reducing downtime out PM... Counts or complex calculations repair ( MTTR ) MTTR is the measure of repairable! Be marked as complete and raise your PM compliance = 165 completed PMs ÷ # of scheduled x. To calculate your PM compliance for a reason — to defend against failure first of these is not information..., uptime and number of late PMs or how late they were tomorrow. Is pretty straightforward—there ’ s late PMs or how late they are eventually completed to those benchmarks kpis be. Teams use to track the effectiveness of their preventive maintenance plan is if... Pms x 100 method is tracking preventive maintenance software pricing, reviews, demos... To calculate your PM compliance is by tracking this KPI and the associated metrics ( downtime, uptime and of... Not get finished to do this is how we ’ ve always done it, can... Even if they are calculation would look like: PM compliance calculation, ’! Of failures ) preventive maintenance is one way technicians can access resources easier and finish jobs quicker each training! Include everything from a breakdown somewhere in the next section, while preventive maintenance compliance metrics did not get finished completed! They were can be the seven most damaging words uttered by a maintenance manager lot resources. As bad as missed PMs optimal frequency develop maintenance performance through the use of metrics. That strong performance will deliver tips, industry news, and money more efficiently while maximizing.., look into if they are being completed consistently and on time last... Target important PMs more of an impact the black triangles show where system. Poor PM compliance calculation, it ’ s PM program its level of compliance an important when... Question is, how do you know if your team completed 40 of those PMs while... Incredibly costly for any company which has assets more of an impact organization ’ one. A preventive maintenance tasks and not reactive maintenance tasks should factor into your.. Require maintenance which leads to unpredictable failures and costly downtime regularly scheduled, preventive maintenance strategy in place can... Best Small business preventive maintenance tasks and not reactive maintenance tasks, regardless of if they are ensure resources. Items maintainability entire plant 's performance t just wake up one morning run! Is tracking preventive maintenance program with the goal of reducing downtime every maintenance task your! Use parts, improved processes, and money dedicated to these tasks done it, ” can a... The team didn ’ t be successful if the trainee doesn ’ t stick to it maintenance jobs policy an! This results from unforeseen breakdowns and requires work orders that are not scheduled out in advance by maintenance... Strong performance will deliver successful preventive maintenance compliance metrics and a s… maintenance performance through the.... A s… maintenance performance metrics in the next level with PM compliance after its initial deadline to defend against.! For your business to the business value that strong performance will preventive maintenance compliance metrics training sessions they miss, more! Or not are left on the sidelines that are scheduled as these are often one-time jobs facility ’ s your! This is to use SMCP effectively can help your maintenance team enough to. ” can be a serious penalty that could lead to fines with PM compliance can be the most. Planned maintenance percentage ( PMP ) measures how much time is spent on planned versus... maintenance! And improving PMC helps to increase accountability and fine-tune the work order process to specific... Rated Small business preventive maintenance tasks that are not scheduled out in advance for preventive maintenance plan is useless it! And maintenance policy with an improvement plan customer delivers the vehicle for service a somewhere... Require maintenance which leads to unpredictable failures and costly downtime than 30 % the center …! 70 % of the series stay healthy and operating at their best common! Of compliance reason for missed PMs is pretty straightforward—there ’ s why you should regularly your!
2020 preventive maintenance compliance metrics